"…if Israel produces the atomic bomb then I believe
that the only answer to such action would be preventive war. The
Arab states will have to take immediate action and liquidate everything
that would enable Israel to produce the atomic bomb."
Excerpts from an Interview with President Nasser,
by Iraqi Newsmen, 20 February 1966
Egypt expressed deep concern over the nuclear reactor that Israel
was allegedly building near Dimona. After an air battle over the
Golan Heights on April 7, 1967, during which six Syrian aircraft
were downed, Egypt announced that it was allying itself with Syria.
Thus, on May 15, Egyptian forces entered the Sinai, in violation
of the agreement signed in 1957, in the wake of the Sinai War. In
addition, Egypt closed the Straits of Tiran
to Israeli ships and ordered UN forces to withdraw from their positions
along the border.
Moscow, humbled by the losses of the April air battle, had already
goaded its Egyptian ally into greater hostility towards Israel as
a way of easing the pressure on Damascus. Soviet officials conjured
up imaginary Israeli troop concentrations on Syria's borders, prompting
Colonel Nasser to mass his own armies at the Egyptian-Israeli frontline
in Sinai. But he even exceeded his mandate from the Soviets when
he dismissed the UN’s truce-monitoring force in the Sinai
Peninsula and mounted a blockade of the Red Sea’s Straits
of Tiran, denying shipping access to the Israeli port of Eilat.
According to Israel's declared national security policy- Egypt's
provocative action called justification for an act of war (casus
beli). But by June 1967, the Israelis found themselves increasingly
surrounded by superior Soviet-backed forces of the Arab and Islamic
world, all of whose leaders were vowing to "throw the Jews
into the sea," and the Israelis were considering a first strike,
before it was too late. But the Soviets had already orchestrated
a strategic plan of their own.
An Egyptian plan to attack Israel codenamed Operation Fajr (Dawn)
was set to start effectively at dawn for May 27, 1967. Another plan,
which was already shaped jointly in November 1966, by Soviet Marshal
Andrei Gretchko and Egyptian Field Marshal Abdel Hakim Amer, was
named "Conqueror" and modeled on clear Soviet strategic
concepts. A detailed report of the joint-Egyptian-Soviet plan was
captured later by the IDF on the Golan Heights from Syrian sources,
including Russian language documents. However, for reasons of political
constraints, directed by highest authority at the time, these were
kept top secret and were only released in part many years later.
Indeed, Israel's political cover-up succeeded so well that Kremlin's
proven responsibility for the Six-Day War had actually been withheld
from the histories of the 1967 conflict until close to its frostiest
anniversary!
The story of Moscow's active involvement in the Six Day War and
its immediate aftermath, the so-called War of Attrition (June 1968-
August 1970) reads like a prefect mystery thriller. It was conducted
by all involved with shrewd manipulations, deceipt and deception
concocted by the best brains of the intelligence trade, in Moscow,
Tel Aviv and Cairo. Moscow's action in 1967 followed a tend in veiled
threats, which Premier Nikolai Bulganin had directed at Israel as
well as Great Britain and France during the so-called 1956 "Suez
Crisis", warning them to halt their activities against Abdul
Nasser's Egypt. A few years later, a similar ploy nearly worked
during the 1962 Cuban missile crisis, only to be averted by a cool-headed
John F Kennedy. Now as tension rose once again in the Middle East,
The Kremlin, under Andrei Kosygin tried this ruse again, this time
against Israel proper.
For decades, it had remained an established consensus among historians,
that the Six Day war broke out by a sequence of mistaken accidents
and misconceptions, perhaps related to a Soviet perception of Israel's
aims against Syria, based on what caused the conflagration over
the Jordan headwaters during the early Sixties. But some of the
recently published studies of the Six-Day War actually hinted at
the fact that the Israeli nuclear dimension played an important
but hidden role in the events leading up to the war, but none of
the books has focused on this aspect. Layers of ambiguity, secrecy
and taboo, in addition to censorship, prevented the story from coming
to light. However, on the occasion of the 40th anniversary of the
war, a duo of reporters challenged this "accident theory"
offering plausible explanation for the real causes of the war. In
their new and well-researched revelations, Isabella Ginor and Gideon
Remez actually argue that the idea over the Six Day War originated
in a scheme by the Soviet Politburo to eliminate Israel's nuclear
facility at Dimona, and with it destroy the Jewish nation's strategic
aspiration to develop nuclear weapons for its ultimate defense.
In their book "Foxbats over Dimona- the Soviets' nuclear gamble
in the Six Day War", (Yale University Press) Ginor and Remez
argue, however, that rather than become involved directly, the Kremlin
devised a complex and shrewd scheme to actually lure the Israelis
into starting a war which would then end with a Soviet destructive
attack on the Dimona complex.
Perhaps the most startling information in the book concerns Moscow's
military preparations during Spring 1967, when the Kremlin prepared
a plan, surrounding Israel with an armada of nuclear-armed naval
forces in the Mediterranean and even pre-positioning military matériel
on land, and training troops nearby with the expectation of using
them physically against Israeli targets. No less as an eye opener,
is to learn from the team that Soviet photo-reconnaissance MiG-25s
(the "Foxbats" of the title) actually overflew the Dimona
nuclear reactor shortly before hostilities started, in May 1967.
This particular disclosure seems however somewhat surprising, based
on the fact, that the the official service year for the first production
model of the Mikoyan-Gurevich MiG-25 (Foxbat) was in 1972. An
earlier still experimental version, designated Ye-266 was a Stripped-down
MiG-25 prototype used to set several speed and altitude records
from 1965 to 1967, could hardly be expected to fly such a dangerous
mission over a highly defended strategic target. To the best of
available records, no operational aircraft of this type was available
in the USSR at the time of the reported recce mission over Dimona.
But this fact does not alter their main conclusion, that the Kremlin
orchestrated the war for their own strategic reasons.
A
book published in Israel, using for the first time IDF documents
from the highest level, revealed the concern among the top brass
and the political level during the two preceding years about an
Egyptian military response to Israeli nuclearization. The top military
and government echelons assessed that the nuclear compound in Dimona
was a major target for an Egyptian surprise attack, especially if
and when Egypt believed Israel was close to producing a nuclear
weapon. Two officially recorded (but withheld) high-altitude aerial
photography flights over Dimona, on May 17 and 26, were indeed critical
for the IDF and the government's understanding of the Egyptians'
intentions. Now Ginor and Remez insist, that the Soviets instigated,
if not flew these dramatic reconnaissance sorties themselves. Whether
these were actually flown by MiG-25 or upgraded versions of the
operational MiG-21 remains debatable, but certainly not significant.
In fact, about 1966 a new version designated MiG-21RF PFM was put
in service as a high altitude interceptor, preceding the MiG-25,
which followed only a few years later. The MiG-21RF (NATO: "Fishbed-J")
a single-seat tactical reconnaissance version of the MiG-21MF, was
recorded flying sorties over Sinai in the early seventies. Another
possibility could have been a sortie by the Soviet high altitude,
long range strategic reconnaissance aircraft designated Yak-25RV
"Mandrake", which could reach 68,000 feet altitude. The
Yakovlev Yak-25 was a direct competitor to the American U-2 spy
plane and was known throughout the sixties flying reconnaissance
sorties in the Middle East.
With Israel's alleged nuclear activities becoming a hot topic in
Cairo and Moscow, the Soviet Navy had already deployed some of its
nuclear submarines to the Mediterranean in early 1967. One of its
captains had received top secret sealed orders to prepare for action,
apparently firing missiles at the Israeli shoreline, when ordered
directly by the Kremlin. More vessels followed shortly as Moscow
offered Cairo a "nuclear umbrella" to safeguard Egypt
against an Israeli nuclear weapons capability. Marshal
Andrei Antonovich Grechko, the Soviet deputy defense minister, actually
had told his Egyptian counterparts in Cairo that the Kremlin had
dispatched "destroyers and submarines to the waters near Egypt,
some armed with missiles and secret weapons" to help wipe out
the Zionists. Thus by the end of May 1967, Soviet amphibious forces
were placed on readiness for action aboard of vessels "visiting"
Port Said and an air component was placed on alert in the Ukraine,
with a small staff group already forward deployed in Egypt.
But then, on June 5th, 1967 the Israeli Defense Forces completely
turned the tables on all involved. Instead of the carefully devised
offensive scheme jointly prepared by Moscow and Cairo, the IDF attacked
with all its might. Preceded by a brilliant deception campaign,
which lulled the Arab air forces into total disarray, the Israeli
air force, using purely conventional weapons only, destroyed three
Arab air forces within hours in a magnificent feat of daring arms,
preparing the way for a lightning campaign on the ground, which
destroyed all three Arab armies, capturing the Sinai Peninsula,
the West Bank of Jordan and the Golan height in a mere six days.
The Kremlin leaders were flabbergasted by Israel's daring exploits,
in face of their quite open threat to intervene actively on the
side of the Arab nations, should Israel attack. Billions of Dollars
worth of Soviet-made arms had been seized or destroyed. Years of
expensive funding to their Arab clients went down the drain and
Soviet prestige was quickly unraveling around the world, especially
in the Arab domain. U.S. intelligence was already picking up signs
of this fear in the Kremlin. In the President's daily brief on June
9, for example, the CIA informed President Johnson that "the
Soviets are finding it hard to conceal their shock over the rapid
Egyptian military collapse. An unidentified Soviet official could
not understand 'how our intelligence could have been so wrong".
But the Kremlin did not give up that easily yet. Within days the
Soviets had recovered and Acting Defense Minister Andrei A. Grechko
and KGB Chairman Yuri V. Andropov were already pressing for the
immediate dispatch of strong Soviet forces to the Middle East. In
their book, Ginor and Remez mention a retired Soviet air force lieutenant
named Yuri V. Nastenko confirming years later, that bomber and fighter
jets, such as the MiG-21s that were under his command and placed
already on highest operational alert on the evening of June 5, 1967,
in what he expected in preparation for "real combat."
Another Russian officer, Yuri N. Khripunkov, a former Soviet naval
commander who was serving on one of 30 Soviet warships that had
been moved from the Black Sea southward to the Mediterranean in
June 1967, also reported being on stand-by for action against Israeli
targets.
But real active Soviet intervention started in earnest during
the so-called War of Attrition only one year later. The deployment
of Soviet units to Egypt was relatively swift, while still gradual.
Organized in the frame of the Operation "Kavkaz", the
first units of the Soviet Air Defense Force, the V-PVO started to
arrive in Egypt equipped with SA-3 SAMs and early warning radars.
A total of three SAM-brigades arrived, one deploying along the Hilwan-Suez
axis, another in the Alexandria area, and a third one defending
Cairo and two other important bases. The first SAM-site was declared
operational by 15 March 1970.
Once these units were in place the V-PVO started deploying manned
fighter jet interceptors, flown by specially selected and highly
trained pilots. The Russian did not risk any chances against the
combat experienced Israeli pilots after their demonstration on June
5th. But Israeli intelligence was not dormant and as soon as the
Soviet pilots were operational in Egypt, their radio traffic was
monitored and carefully recorded. After losing several F-4 Phantom
jets, to Soviet SAMs, the Israeli air force went over to try and
confront the Russian pilots in aerial combat. Their chance came
on July 30 shortly after midday, when two Phantoms attacked an Egyptian
radar site on the Gulf of Suez, escorted by a Mirage III finger-four
formation, flying high-cover As expected the Russian pilots took
off to engage, scrambling no less than eight new MiG-21MF (J-type).
In the dogfight that followed, five MiGs were shot down. Of the
Russian pilots only one managed to eject safely, while the remaining
four died in the action. It was the last time that Russian pilots
engaged Israeli flyers. Soon after, a cease fire was arranged, which
more or less held until October 6, 1973 when the Yom Kippur War
started.
During 1971 Israeli and US intelligence tracked several Soviet
reconnaissance flights over Sinai and southern Israel. Those included
suspected MiG-25R Foxbat B versions, which may have overflown the
Dimona complex as well. None were intercepted, but one pilot, flying
at top speed, to escape interception, which actually wrecked the
engines on landing at an Egyptian airfield.
A the end of the 1973 Yom Kippur War, the Soviets once again threatened
Israel with nuclear intervention. With the IDF having crossed the
Suez Canal into Egypt and surounding the Egyptian Third Army near
Suez, the Russians became alarmed. There were intelligence reports
that a Soviet ship allegedly carrying nuclear weapons had docked
in Alexandria. Soviet Premier Leonid Brezhnev threatened on 24 October,
airlifting Soviet airborne troops to reinforce the Egyptians, cut
off on the eastern side of the Suez Canal. No less than seven Soviet
airborne divisions were placed on high alert. This action immediately
prompted US President Richard Nixon's counter action with the US
military technically placed at DEFCON 3 status. Under this US Pershing
I missiles, stationed in West Germany, were also placed on high
alert status for immediate action. Once again, the world came on
the brink of global nuclear conflict, which luckily was averted
at the last moment, when Israel Prime Minister Golda Meir agreed
to a cease-fire, relieving the pressure on the Egyptian Third Army.
|